Anything by Laurie Halse Anderson has to be worth reading, right? And I read Dear Julia: it was ok, but nothing to rave about.
.-= Melissa (Book Nut)´s last blog ..Perfect Chemistry =-.

I liked If I Stay, and it was pretty quick. I don’t know any of the rest of them.
.-= Lisa´s last blog ..Organize your shelves by color? (TSS) =-.

If I Stay, hands down. A fast read and SO good.
.-= Janssen´s last blog ..Hate List by Jennifer Brown =-.

Catalyst = probably my fave LHA book

If I Stay = a good enough read and QUICK, so you could probably do it

I couldn’t get into I Know It’s Over but my 16yo sister read it and liked it, so I’d try it out.

Otherwise, renew renew RENEW!

As another data point, I looked up the average Goodreads and LibraryThing ratings for each of these titles. Goodreads is first, then LibraryThing:

• Catalyst: 3.60, 3.67
• Dear Julia: 3.42, 3.61
• If I Stay: 4.05, 4.28
• I Know It’s Over: 3.76, 3.72
• The Flying Troutmans: 3.74, 3.73
• My Heartbeat: 3.80, 3.75
• Say the Word: 3.96, 3.83

Looks like If I Stay is the clear winner from that test!
.-= Kelly’s last blog: Say Yeah or Nay on My Library Loot =-.

Melissa, with Jessica’s glowing review of Catalyst, I think you’re right & that one should stay!

Dear Julia is going back. Thanks for the heads up!

Lisa, that makes you, Janssen, & Jessica chiming in to say If I Stay, so it’s staying! Thanks for helping me decide.

Janssen, okay, that one’s staying. Thanks!

Jessica: Good to hear that about Catalyst. It’s saved from the chopping block. If I Stay is saved too, and I’ll see if I can get to I Know It’s Over.

I already renewed all these titles a week ago so I’m running out of time! I don’t know why I don’t just check them out again, but there’s something about that library deadline that gets to me…